CLV versus CLV
What goes wrong when a company ranks its customers only by lifetime value.
Perspective matters a lot. In this day and age, people have opinions about everything, and because of the vast amount of information available those opinions may very well come from a thousand different angles. Perspective matters a lot. One of the things that I've noticed as I spend more and more time studying culture and business development is that history impacts everything, and by everything I mean perspective. History can teach us a lot about how to do business, but unless those lessons are fully broken down and analyzed at their deepest levels, there's a very good chance they get passed down from one generation to the next with a horrible defect. Perspective matters a lot. I will always be a philosopher first, and a businessman second. Because of that, I've missed out on being saturated in business culture from an early age, but I've also avoided being indoctrinated. I'm a huge believer of the concept described above, breaking things down to their core components, and investigating the value systems that make those components tick. Perspective matters a lot.
There seems to be a trend in traditional business to prioritize CLV, that is, Customer Lifetime Value. CLV is a way of measuring the value of your customers long-term, while also enabling marketers to compare acquisition tactics and their cost to that customer's value. This creates a focus: "How do I find more customers like my best customers?" At a glance, and even in practice, this can be a great tactic and/or strategy. Deep in this concept's foundation, however, I can see a crack.
A lot of the time, a philosopher's job is to boil down equations of cause and effect. That naturally makes sense; our favorite question is "why". Here's why that's powerful: based on the above definitions of CLV, let's investigate how a company's culture focused on it can be precarious. CLV creates a value system that can distinguish one customer from the next. Customers come with their own lifetime of data, and all of it, be it habits and behavior, genetic disposition, stereotypical trends and other demographic statistics, can be broken down and quantified. Breaking down the customer into a collection of 1's and 0's and pairing them with an overarching "customer lifetime value" is the next step in this process. Once this is done, marketers can quantify how many customers in any given market fall into Segments A, B, and C (demographic concept examples) and prioritize them by a system aligned with what the company decides their ideal TA, target audience, and customer is. To see this in practice let's assign the above TA with customer lifetime values. Segment A's lifetime value is 100, Segment B's is 13, and Segment C's is 42. Segment B is obviously made up of frugal consumers, and has a low CLV. Our example company obviously won't invest much in that customer segment, right? Segment C's CLV is much higher than Segment B's, and should by practice beg a higher investment from our company. Finally we have Segment A. As seen, Segment A's CLV dwarfs all others by comparison, dictating that Segment A is the most valuable customer in this company's TA. Now let's assume that the cost of acquiring each customer segment is the same, but each segment requires a distinct marketing campaign to reach. What does a company prioritizing CLV and finding "more customers like my best customers" do? They very logically invest in developing Segment A to its fullest potential, and because our company can spend the same amount on any segment, they prioritize Segment A time and time again, because the ROI that segment represents is more valuable to our company. This comes with an unintended consequence: because Segment A is so valuable, Segments B and C continue to stay neglected and underdeveloped. Why? Because our company doesn't care about them. When your company does special promotions, who gets the emails? Segment A does. When we open a brick and mortar location, who do we design the shopping experience to benefit most? Segment A, of course.
By this point you should see the creation of a trend in our company's behavior. Segment A is the only segment that our company is creating value for. Our hypothetical company has abandoned even considering Segments B and C as a viable option. Even though Segments B and C initially represented a total CLV of 55, their values diminish because their value hasn't been "mined or refined". An effect like this can be compounded if our company was a store like many jewelers, who often train their sales associates to identify market segments as they walk in the door, and respond relative to the customer's projected value. This kind of company culture should set off warning signs, red flags as they say. I would venture to say that this kind of behavior is even unethical.
Prioritizing ROI and CLV when creating value for your customers dehumanizes businesses into money-hungry machines. Segment A almost doesn't matter either; the only thing that company cared about in this experiment is the value that Segment A represented. The customers who make up Segment A don't matter as people, but only by their Segment A shopping behavior.